Something to doWhat's next
Ask what they'd keep and change about their work
A conversation to help someone you care about work out what they'd keep in their job, and what they'd change
Why it’s worth your time
Not liking a job is rarely about all of it at once. Taking it one layer at a time, from the field they're in to the person they report to, helps someone see which part is the trouble and which part they'd keep. What the answers mean is theirs to decide.
How to help someone work out what isn't working in their job
You’ll come away with a short list, in their words, of what they'd want more of and less of next time.
We’ll turn this into a checklist you can tick off.
- Start with what they're trying to work out.
Not the plan, which can feel like a test, but what's on their mind and what matters most to them in whatever comes next. Then ask what they're good at and enjoy. Someone asked only about problems usually ends up describing only problems.
You“What are you trying to work out right now? And what's a part of your work you're good at and actually enjoy?” - Go through the layers one at a time.
The industry, the company, the role, the team, the boss. Go one pair at a time, down to the role but not the team, and the team but not the boss. For each layer, ask what they'd want more of next time, and less of. Mixed answers are normal: someone can love their field and be worn out by their company, or like the work and dread one person.
You“Let's take it apart a bit. Do you like the industry but not the company? Or the company but not the role?”Tip: If they're between jobs, ask about the last one. More of and less of works just as well looking back.
- Say back the pattern you heard.
Keep it short and in your own words, something like: it sounds like the team is what you'd keep, and the role is what you'd change. Then check. If they correct you, the correction is often the most useful thing said all conversation.
You“Can I say back what I'm hearing? Tell me where I've got it wrong.” - Leave what it means with them.
Ask what stands out to them, and stop there. You may see an obvious next step. They may see a different one, or none yet, and working that out is theirs to do.
You“What do you make of that?”Tip: If you hear yourself starting a sentence with you should, turn it into a question.
Good moments for this: when someone says work isn't going wellwhen they're weighing a changeafter a job ends, about the last one
We’ll turn this into a checklist you can tick off.
Keep going with Truest
Small actions add up. Truest helps you find the next thing worth doing, make the space to do it, and keep a record of your progress. It’s a private place to work on your career, and it’s yours, not your employer’s.
- It actually happensDo it now, and you’ve invested in your career today.
- You know what’s nextTruest suggests the next small thing to try, based on what you’re working on.
- It’s yours to keepEach thing you do is saved to your private record, there when your next review or job search comes around.
Anything else we can help you with this week?
Making it work for you
Every workplace is different. Here’s what to think about before you start, and what might get in the way.
Things to think about
Maybe you've never liked the sound of their boss, or you have views about their industry. Those can wait. The conversation goes further when the only opinions in it are theirs.
What might make this harder
Take that seriously for now, and ask about the least bad part, or the best day they've had there lately. If it still sounds like all of it, or like more than work, stop asking about layers and just listen.
Questions people ask
What questions can I ask a friend who is unhappy at work?
Begin with what's on their mind, then take the job apart: the field, the employer, the work itself, the people, the manager. Which of those would they keep, and which would they change? That's easier to answer than whether they should quit.
How do I help someone decide whether to quit their job?
Rather than stay or go, help them see which part isn't working. Whether it's the boss, the team, the role or the field itself changes what their options look like. Either way, the decision is theirs.
Do I need to know someone's field to help them think about their career?
No. Questions about what they'd want more of and less of work in any field, and they're the expert on their own job.
Why this works, and where it comes from
When work isn't going well, it usually comes out as one big feeling: I don't like my job. From the inside, a job can feel like a single thing you either like or don't, when it's really several things stacked together. The field, the company, the particular role, the people beside you and the one person you report to can each be going well or badly on their own. Two people with the same title can have very different weeks because of the bottom two layers alone.
Asking about each layer separately turns a verdict into a map. Someone who'd keep the work and change the team is in a different spot from someone who'd keep the team and change the field, and they may not see which one they are until they hear themselves say it. That's why the say-back matters. People often recognize their own pattern faster when someone else hands it back to them. Handing it back isn't deciding for them. It's a mirror, and they're free to tell you it's crooked.
It's easy to assume you're no use here if you don't know their field. It often works the other way. Someone who knows the field is tempted to answer the questions themselves; someone who doesn't has to ask, and then has to listen. Good questions and real attention do most of the work, and neither needs expertise.
This isn't the conversation for the week someone loses a job or gets hard news. Taking their work apart then can feel like a post-mortem, and asking how they are, then listening, is the better move. It also doesn't suit someone who has already decided and is telling you about it; they're past sorting, and understanding where they're headed matters more than going back over the old job. And if what's wrong seems bigger than work, set the layers aside and follow their lead.
More in What's next
See allRead this alongside your role page
Is this page helpful? Our small team would love to know.
We're here to help you grow your career. We'd love your help growing Truest.
Truest is a small public benefit corporation (fewer than five people). We sell subscriptions, not ads or your data, so any help is appreciated!
An exercise written by Truest, based on our experience. Last updated November 20, 2026. We sell a career membership; where that’s relevant above, we say so.