Career advice

How to ask someone about their career without putting them on the spot

Easy ways to ask how someone's work is going, so they can share as much or as little as they like.

Why it’s worth your time

Whether they're between jobs, unsure about the job they have, on a path you don't quite get or just starting out, how you ask tends to shape what you hear. A question they can easily decline often gets a more honest answer, and sometimes a chance to help.

Read moreShow less

If they'd rather not talk about it, letting it go warmly can be the kindest thing you do that day. If they're up for more, a short story of your own and a few good questions tend to help more than advice, and one small offer can go further than a list of ideas.

The short version

  1. The short versionTell them you're asking because you care, and give them a real way out of talking about work.
  2. 2 of 3If they're up for it, share a time you didn't know what was next, then ask what they're trying to work out.
  3. 3 of 3Hold off on telling them what to do. If they'd like help, offer one specific thing they can easily turn down.

What to understand about asking someone how work is going

Asking about work is one of the most ordinary things people do, and that's part of the trouble. It's the same question whether someone's job is going well or quietly coming apart, so the person asked has to decide in a second how much truth to hand over, sometimes with others listening. Work is also tied up with how a lot of people see themselves. A light question can touch something heavier than the job, and "oh, fine" is often the safest thing to say.

Most of the room is in what kind of answer your question asks for. Some ask for a verdict: did you get it, are you staying, what's the plan. Others ask for a description: what a normal week looks like, what's surprised them. A description has no wrong answer, so it tends to be easier to give, and it's often where the interesting part is. What you do with the answer matters too. Meet an honest answer with a quick fix, and people tend to give the stock one next time.

The hard part is how little you can see or do from outside. You can't always tell how much someone is carrying, and most of what moves a career along happens slowly, through their own tries and decisions, out of your view. You might be someone they open up to, or someone they'd rather keep it light with, and that's often about the relationship and the timing more than how well you asked. Caring how someone's doing doesn't give you a claim on the details, even when you're worried.

What people often get wrong about asking

  • You might think“Asking how the search is going is the best way to show I care.”
    More oftenIt can feel that way from your side. From theirs, how you ask tends to count for more, and if you're worried about them, the worry can slip into the question and turn a kind one into an interrogation. Saying you're asking because you care, with an easy way out, lets them decide how much to share.One thing to try: Sort what you know from what you're guessing →
  • You might think“It works the way it did when I went through it.”
    More oftenOften it doesn't. How people find work, how long it takes and what a career path looks like can all be different now, even from a few years ago. Being curious about how it works for them tends to open more than advice from how it worked for you.One thing to try: Ask them how it works these days →
  • You might think“Good advice is the most useful thing I can give.”
    More oftenAdvice tends to land best once someone has asked for it, and your path, your advice and your contacts may not carry over to their world. What often does carry over is how you worked through not knowing: what you tried, who you asked and how you decided.One thing to try: Ask before you advise →
  • You might think“They should have it figured out by now.”
    More oftenAlmost nobody has it figured out, at any age. There's often a lot of pressure to know what you want early on, and plenty of people find their way after a stretch of not knowing. Hearing about a time you didn't know what you wanted can make not knowing easier to talk about, as long as you don't claim theirs is the same.One thing to try: Check the story you're telling yourself →

What to say, depending on how much they want to share

Before you ask about their work

If it suits them, give a heads-up before you see them

Send a short note saying you'd love to hear how they're doing, and that skipping work talk is fine. This suits some people and not others.

Hey, I'd love to hear how things are going, but if you'd prefer not to talk about it, just let me know. I'm mostly just excited to see you, I care about how you're doing, and I'm curious how things work these days!

It lets them decide before they arrive, not on the spot. For someone who'd rather the topic never came up, though, the note itself can be one more mention, so it's a call you make about this person.

Say why you're asking, and give them a real way out

Say you're asking because you care and you're curious, not to check up on them. Then make skipping it easy, and mean it.

You don't have to talk about work if you don't want to. I'm asking because I care how you're doing, and I'm curious how things work these days.

When someone's in a hard stretch, a direct question about the job can feel like a progress check. Saying why you're asking, with an easy out, tends to make it feel like care, and they may say more because they chose to.

Go further:Let them decide how much to talk about work →

If they'd rather not get into it

Let it go warmly, and ask about something else

Say one kind line that drops the topic, then ask about something they enjoy. Leave it there for the rest of the day.

Of course. Tell me what else has been going on with you.

A no here is the way out doing its job, not the conversation failing. Letting it go easily can tell them you asked because you care, and that may make you the person they come back to when they're ready.

Go further:Close a topic in one kind sentence, then ask about them →

If they're up for talking about it

  1. Share a time you didn't know what was next

    Tell a short story about a time you weren't sure what you wanted, or what was hard about it, and what you did. Keep it as your story, since theirs is probably different, then hand it back with a question.

    There was a stretch when I had no idea what I wanted, and it took me a while to work it out. It's probably different for you. What's it been like?

    Hearing that someone they know didn't have it figured out can make their own stretch feel more ordinary. A short story tends to work better than a long one, because it leaves room for theirs.

    If the question lands on them at a big table, start a round of stories

    Ask the whole table for a story: the worst job they ever had, or a time they weren't sure what came next. Go first, so the spotlight moves off them.

    Okay, new game. Worst job you ever had, everybody. I'll go first.

    Go further:Share a time you didn't know what was next →Share the spotlight with a round of worst-job stories →

  2. Ask what they're trying to work out, and what they'd want more of

    Ask what matters to them right now, and what they're good at and enjoy. Then take the parts of work one at a time: the industry, the company, the role, the team and the boss. What would they want more of next time, and less of?

    What are you trying to work out right now? I'm curious what matters most to you in whatever comes next.

    Questions like these tend to be easier to answer than "what's the plan?", and you don't need to know their field to ask them. The answers can help them see what they're looking for, often more than a suggestion from you would.

    Go further:Ask what they'd keep and change about their work →Ask before you advise →

  3. Offer one specific kind of help they can easily turn down

    Name one thing you could do: an introduction, a practice run, a read of something they wrote, or just listening. Make no an easy answer, and ask before you mention them to anyone.

    Would it help if I introduced you to someone I know in that world? It's completely fine if not.

    People often don't ask for help because they aren't sure what to ask for. One specific offer tends to be easier to say yes to than "let me know if I can help", and easy to decline if it isn't what they need.

    Go further:Offer one kind of help they can turn down →

They're between jobs

“I know they're looking, and I don't want to make it harder by asking.”

Let them choose whether to talk about it. If they do, start with how they're doing, not the search, then offer one specific thing you could do.

Maybe: They may be glad to talk it over with someone who isn't keeping score, and a question with an easy out lets them decide.

Or: They may be tired of the topic, and a day off from it, spent on anything else, could be the most welcome thing you offer.

What we’d suggest

Say why you're asking, and give them a real way out

I've been thinking about you. How are you doing with everything? We can talk about the search, or not at all.

Offer one specific kind of help they can easily turn down

Would it help if I introduced you to someone I know in that world? It's completely fine if not.

They're working, and not sure it's the one

“They keep saying work is fine, and it doesn't sound fine.”

Ask which part of the job they'd keep and which they'd change. It's easier to answer than "are you going to quit?", and it can help them see where the trouble is.

Maybe: It may be an ordinary rough patch, the kind many people talk through and stay, and being heard could be all they want.

Or: They may be closer to a decision than they've said, and questions about which part they'd change could help them see it.

What we’d suggest

Say why you're asking, and give them a real way out

You don't have to talk about work if you don't want to. I'm asking because I care how you're doing, and I'm curious how things work these days.

Ask what they're trying to work out, and what they'd want more of

If you could keep one part of your job and change the rest, which part would you keep?

They chose a path you don't quite get

“They've told me what they do a few times, and I still couldn't explain it.”

Ask what a normal week looks like and what they like about it. If you have doubts about where it's headed, try to understand it before you say anything. It's their career, and curiosity about the work can mean more to them than a question about whether it'll work out.

Maybe: They may have explained it many times already, and a question about their week could be a welcome change from defending the choice.

Or: Some of your doubt may be your own worry about the path, more than anything they've said about it.

What we’d suggest

Say why you're asking, and give them a real way out

You don't have to talk about work if you don't want to. I'm asking because I care how you're doing, and I'm curious how things work these days.

Ask what they're trying to work out, and what they'd want more of

What does a normal week look like for you? I'd like to be able to picture it.

They're just starting out

“Everyone keeps asking them what's next, and I don't want to be one more.”

Give them the out, tell them a little about your own start, then ask what they've enjoyed so far. Hearing that your own start was messy can ease some of the pressure to have it all worked out.

Maybe: They may be hearing "so what's next?" from everyone, and a question about what they've enjoyed could be a relief.

Or: They may know exactly what they want and be stuck on how to get in, which is where a practice run or an introduction can help.

What we’d suggest

Say why you're asking, and give them a real way out

You don't have to talk about this if you don't want to. I'm just curious how things work these days compared to when I was younger.

Share a time you didn't know what was next

When I was younger, I had a hard time figuring out what I even wanted, and my first job was nothing like I expected. It's probably different now. What's it been like for you?

Ask what they're trying to work out, and what they'd want more of

What have you enjoyed most so far, in school or any job you've had?

The harder part is that they don't know what they want

“They don't seem to know what they want, and I'm not sure how to help with that.”

Skip the plan. Share a stretch when you didn't know what you wanted, and say it was probably different from theirs. Then ask about the parts of work they've liked. Hearing it from you may make not knowing feel more ordinary.

Maybe: Not knowing may be a stage they're working through, and questions about what they've liked could give them somewhere to start.

Or: They may already have pieces of an answer, and just haven't had a reason to put them into words.

What we’d suggest

Share a time you didn't know what was next

There was a stretch when I had no idea what I wanted, and it took me a while to work it out. It's probably different for you. What's it been like?

Ask what they're trying to work out, and what they'd want more of

Forget the plan for a minute. What's a job, or part of one, that you've really liked?

What changes how you'd handle it

  • How close you are

    Someone you talk to every week may welcome the fuller conversation, and a heads-up before you see them. Someone you see once a year may prefer a light question and an easy way out.

  • Whether you know their field

    If you do, you may have specific ideas or people to introduce, offered once and easy to decline. If you don't, ask what they're working out and share how you handled a change of your own.

  • How fresh it is

    For a few weeks after a layoff or a hard no, being heard often counts for more than any idea. Later on, a specific offer may be more welcome.

  • Who else is around

    Just the two of you, there's room for the longer conversation. With others listening, a lighter question, or a round of stories, keeps the spotlight off them.

  • Whether they've come to you before

    If they've asked your view in the past, they may want it again, once they've had their say. If they haven't, let them lead and keep your ideas for when they ask.

How the question changes through a career

  1. Starting out

    Questions about the plan can feel heavy when there isn't one yet. Asking what they've enjoyed so far, in school or any job, tends to be easier to answer, and a story about your own first job can help.

  2. A few years in

    "Still at that place?" can sound like a comment on their pace. Asking what they've learned, or what they'd keep from the job, often gets a fuller answer.

  3. Further along

    People may assume they've arrived. After a layoff or a long stretch in one place, asking what they'd want more of next can open a real conversation, and you may know someone worth meeting.

  4. Later on

    The question often turns to retirement. Asking what they'd like the coming years to hold, at work or outside it, can be more welcome than asking when they'll stop.

What might make this harder

  • Someone else at the table keeps pressing them.

    Step in once. Ask the person pressing about their own year, or start a round of stories. Later, a quiet word to the person who was pressed, like "that looked like a lot," can mean more than anything said at the table.

  • It seems heavier than work, or rawer than you expected.

    Stop asking about work and listen. "That sounds hard" can be enough for now. Whether and how to come back to it is your call.

  • You're not happy about where they're headed.

    Try to understand it before you say anything about it: what draws them to it, and what they hope it leads to. Hold back the criticism. It's their career, and your support is likely to matter more to them than your view of it.

    Understand where they're headed before you weigh in →
  • They take the way out every time you ask.

    That's an answer, and a fair one. Ask about the rest of their life instead, and say once that you're around if they ever want to think it through. Some people come back to it in their own time.

    Check in a month later →

Worth doing before you see them

Each of these is worth doing on its own. They also make this conversation easier.

Questions people ask

What do you say to someone who just lost their job?

Something short and warm, with no fixes attached: "I'm sorry, that's a lot. How are you doing?" Then follow their lead. Ideas, introductions and job leads tend to land better a little later, once they've said they'd like them.

How do I ask about someone's job search without being nosy?

Say you're asking because you care, and leave the search as one option: "We can talk about it or skip it." If they want to talk, ask what they've liked about the roles they're looking at. Counts, like how many applications they've sent, can feel like a scorecard.

How can I help someone figure out what they want to do?

Ask more than you advise. Questions about what they've liked and what they'd want more of, in the industry, the company, the role, the team and the boss, can help them see it for themselves. A short story about a time you didn't know what you wanted can help too, if you keep it about you.

Should I offer to introduce someone to people I know?

Often, yes, if you ask them first and make it easy to say no. Let them choose who they'd like to meet, and check with the other person before you connect them, so the introduction is welcome on both sides.

What shouldn't you say to someone who's unemployed?

Questions that work like a scorecard, such as how many interviews they've had, can sting. So can quick fixes like "have you tried calling companies directly?" Asking how they are, and what would help, usually goes further.

What will you do next?

  • On your own

    Before you see them, pick the one question you'd most like to ask, and the easy way out you'll offer with it.

  • With Truest

    Sometimes career advice can land better when it doesn't come from someone they know. If that might be true here, you could give them a year of Truest as a gift, so they have room to grow in their career on their own terms. Truest can help with working out what's next and keeping a week-by-week record of what they get done. They get an email with a code to start, and whether they use it is up to them.

    See how membership works →Give someone a year of Truest →
  • With your AI

    A prompt that has your AI play the person you want to ask, so you can practice.

Tell Truest what you’re dealing with

We read every one, and we write guides for the things that come up most. Leave your email if you’d like to hear when we do.