Something to doChanging jobs

Listen without trying to fix it

A simple exercise to help someone you care about feel heard after hard news at work

Why it’s worth your time

Right after bad news, being understood usually helps more than being advised.

One way to do it

How to listen without giving advice

You’ll come away with a conversation where they did most of the talking, and a clearer sense of what they want from you.

We’ll turn this into a checklist you can tick off.

  1. Open with how they are, not with what happened.

    Skip the details, the timeline and the plan for now. Ask about them, and let them choose where to start.

    You“I'm so sorry. How are you doing with all of it?”

    Tip: A setting with no clock on it helps. Side by side, on a walk or in the car, many people find hard things easier to say than across a table.

  2. Say back what you heard, and check you got it.

    Every so often, put what they said into your own words, especially the part that seems to hurt most. If they say the layoff came out of nowhere and they keep replaying the last few months, you might try: so the shock is the worst of it, more than the job itself? If you've got it wrong, they'll tell you, and now you both know.

    You“Let me make sure I've got this. Is that the hardest part?”

    Tip: Use your own words rather than repeating their sentence back. An exact echo can sound like a technique.

  3. Hold your ideas, leads and silver linings.

    Ideas will come: someone they should call, a job you saw last week, the reason this might be for the best. Keep them for later. Silver linings count too, since "at least you got severance" can sound like "you can stop being upset now." If one idea really won't wait, ask once whether they want ideas or just want to talk, and take the answer as given.

    You“Do you want ideas right now, or would you rather just talk it through? Either is completely fine.”

    Tip: Jot the ideas down afterward if they keep nagging at you. They'll keep, and you'll have them if they ask.

  4. Catch yourself fixing, and hand it back.

    You'll probably slip at some point; most people who care do. When you notice you've started solving, stop, say so, and go back to them.

    You“Sorry, I'm jumping to fixing it. Tell me more about what it's been like.”
  5. Close without a plan.

    Say you're glad they told you, and that you're around. No homework, no next steps, no list of things you could do for them.

    You“I'm really glad you told me. I'm around whenever you want to talk again.”

Good moments for this: the first time you talk after their bad newswhenever they bring it up againany time they need to vent more than solve

We’ll turn this into a checklist you can tick off.

If this was useful

Keep going with Truest

Small actions add up. Truest helps you find the next thing worth doing, make the space to do it, and keep a record of your progress. It’s a private place to work on your career, and it’s yours, not your employer’s.

  • It actually happensDo it now, and you’ve invested in your career today.
  • You know what’s nextTruest suggests the next small thing to try, based on what you’re working on.
  • It’s yours to keepEach thing you do is saved to your private record, there when your next review or job search comes around.

Making it work for you

Every workplace is different. Here’s what to think about before you start, and what might get in the way.

Things to think about

After they've said something hard, a pause isn't a gap you need to fill. Wait a few seconds; people often say the most important thing next.

What might make this harder

You don't have to agree to listen. Reflect how it felt to them, something like "it sounds like you felt blindsided," without ruling on who was right. A fuller view, if there is one, often arrives on its own once they've been heard.

Questions people ask

What do you say to someone who just got laid off?

Something short and kind, then a question about them rather than the job, like "That's rotten news. How are you holding up?" Then mostly listen. Leads and ideas can wait until they say they'd like some.

How do I listen without giving advice?

Ask how they are, put what you heard into your own words, and check you got it right. If an idea won't wait, ask whether they'd like ideas or would rather talk it through, and go with the answer.

What should you not say to someone after bad news at work?

Quick fixes, silver linings and stories about how it worked out for someone else. Each can sound like a cue to move on before they're ready. A plain "I'm sorry," and a question about how they are, usually does more.

What is active listening?

A common name for listening closely and showing it: letting the other person talk, saying back what you heard, and checking you understood before you add anything of your own.

The longer read

Why this works, and where it comes from

Telling someone bad news has a cost. You have to say it out loud, watch their face, and then deal with whatever they do with it. When the reply is a plan, the person who just shared something hard can end up reassuring you that they'll be fine. Most of us know that moment from the other side: a friend starts listing contacts, and you quietly stop saying what you meant to say.

Saying back what you heard does more than it looks like. It catches the places you've misunderstood, and it lets them hear their own situation from the outside, which is sometimes how people work out what they think. That's why the ideas wait. Not because they're bad, but because someone who doesn't yet feel understood tends to have little room for them.

More in Changing jobs

See all

Read this alongside your role page

A note from the team

Is this page helpful? Our small team would love to know.

We're here to help you grow your career. We'd love your help growing Truest.

Truest is a small public benefit corporation (fewer than five people). We sell subscriptions, not ads or your data, so any help is appreciated!

Subscribe to TruestWeekly check-ins and a record of your career that belongs to you.

An exercise written by Truest, based on our experience. Last updated November 20, 2026. We sell a career membership; where that’s relevant above, we say so.